diff --git a/cardsim/terminalui.go b/cardsim/terminalui.go
index b6dc9b2..0f32ccf 100644
--- a/cardsim/terminalui.go
+++ b/cardsim/terminalui.go
@@ -143,7 +143,7 @@ func pickNextAction[C StatsCollection](p *Player[C]) (isCard bool, cardIdx int,
 				}
 			} else {
 				i = i - handOffset - 1
-				option, promptErr := promptCard(p, p.Hand[i-handOffset-1])
+				option, promptErr := promptCard(p, p.Hand[i])
 				if option >= 0 || IsSeriousError(promptErr) {
 					return true, i, option, nil
 				}